The First “Emergency” Cease and Desist Order Against Verizon Cell Tower by the Board of Health Pittsfield MA
EMERGENCY ORDER
REQUIRING THAT PITTSFIELD CELLULAR TELEPHONE COMPANY, D/B/A VERIZON WIRELESS, AND FARLEY WHITE SOUTH STREET, LLC, SHOW CAUSE WHY THE PITTSFIELD BOARD OF HEALTH SHOULD NOT ISSUE A CEASE AND DESIST ORDER ABATING A NUISANCE AT 877 SOUTH STREET ARISING FROM THE OPERATION OF A VERIZON WIRELESS CELL TOWER THEREON AND CONSTITUTING IMMEDIATE ORDER OF DISCONTINUANCE AND ABATEMENT IF NO HEARING IS REQUESTED
First in Nation; Board of Health Sends Emergency Cease & Desist Order for Verizon Cell Tower After Health Effects Reported
On April 6, 2022, the Pittsfield, Massachusetts Board of Health voted to send a cease and desist order to shut down a Verizon cell tower if Verizon does not respond with meaningful action regarding a cell tower . The Board took action after families living in the neighborhood of Shacktown near the tower on 877 South Street Pittsfield MA reported wireless radiation-related health issues soon after the tower became operational in 2020.
The order was sent this week and recieved by Verizon today. Verizon has seven days to respond. Seventeen people are reporting injuries linked to the radiation.
The order states that verizon cell tower was activated, “the City started to receive reports of illness and negative health symptoms from residents living nearby the facility, and in particular, from residents living in the so-called “Shacktown” neighborhood. The negative health symptoms the affected residents have reported include complaints of headaches, sleep problems, heart palpitations, tinnitus (ringing in the ears), dizziness, nausea, skin rashes, and memory and cognitive problems, among other medical complaints.”
“The evidence presented to the Board includes well over one thousand peer-reviewed scientific and medical studies which consistently find that pulsed and modulated RFR has bio-effects and can lead to short- and long-term adverse health effects in humans…Credible, independent peer-reviewed scientific and medical studies show profoundly deleterious effects on human health, including but not limited to: neurological and dermatological effects; increased risk of cancer and brain tumors; DNA damage; oxidative stress; immune dysfunction; cognitive processing effects; altered brain development, sleep and memory disturbances, ADHD, abnormal behavior, sperm dysfunction, and damage to the blood-brain barrier.”
“Whereas, as further documented below, the neurological and dermatological symptoms experienced by the residents are consistent with those described in the peer-reviewed scientific and medical literature as being associated with exposure to pulsed and modulated Radio Frequency (“RF”) radiation, including RF from cell towers.”
Shacktown resident Courtney Gilardi, whose two daughters are among the injured stated, “We pray that the Honorable Mayor Tyer supports the Board of Health’s decision and stands with the 17 harmed and the three with cancer. We pray she honor’s the Board of Health’s careful, conscientious and unanimous decision. We pray she frees up funds for the Board to be able to do their work. We pray we are not the collateral damage, the cost of doing business or the disposable people like we have been called. We pray this cease and desist results in the tower being removed.” Read Courtney Gilardi’s full statement.
The community, supported by physicians and international experts has been working tirelessly to turn the Verizon towers transmissions off.
Next: The Pittsfield City Council must now vote on releasing monies to support legal action to defend against Verizon.
Background: Two months ago, the Board voted to issue a cease and desist order but held off from actually sending it to Verizon as they finalized the document and addressed legal issues. Now, they have prepared a final cease and desist. However the Board has concerns that if Verizon sues the City for the action, the City Mayor Tyer will not release the funds for legal defense. Thus, yesterdays historic vote was conditioned on the order being withdrawn without prejudice if the board is unable to retain legal counsel prior to any administrative or judicial proceeding.
The Board of Health held a Forum on cell tower radiation and health July 2, 2021.
Local News Reports
- The Pittsfield Board of Health issued a cease-and-desist order to Verizon. Now it’s looking for an attorney to back it up | Central Berkshires | berkshireeagle.com
- Pittsfield Health Board Seeking Funds to Stop Cell Tower / iBerkshires.com
Links
- Pittsfield Board of Health Wireless Harm Expert Forum:
- Watch testimony from April 6, 2022 Board of Health Meeting
- Watch full board of Health Deliberations on April 6, 2022
- Pittsfield MA Expert Forum on Cell Tower Cease-and-Desist Order
The Board heard testimony from numerous doctors and experts:
- Cindy Russell MD to Council Members in the City of Pittsfield, Cindy Russell MD Second Letter
- David Carpenter MD to Mayor of the City of Pittsfield MA and Board of Health on Cell Tower Radiation
- Dr. Kulberg Chair of Pittsfield Board of Health to the Joint Committee on Consumer Protection RE: Senate Bill S.186 and in Support of MA Commission on Wireless Radiation
- Magda Havas PhD to Gina Armstrong, Director of Public Health, Pittsfield Health Department Slide Presentation
- Paul Héroux, PhD, McGill University Medicine Comments on RF EMISSION STUDY
- Peter White, Councilor City of Pittsfield to Massachusetts State Legislature in Favor of Wireless Right to Know Legislation
- Theodora Scarato, Environmental Health Trust to Pittsfield Board of Health, Dr. Devra Davis et al letter on Wireless Radiation , Myth Fact Scientific Response EHT 2022
- Sheena Symington to Pittsfield Board of Health
- Kent Chamberlin PhD to Editor of the Berkshire Eagle Re; Opinion on Verizon Cell Tower.
- Sharon Goldberg MD Wireless Health Effects Slides
Two months ago, on February 2, 2022, the Pittsfield, Massachusetts Board of Health had unanimously voted to issue an order but they had not finalized the order and wanted to consult with lawyers before further action. The cease and desist order to Verizon would become effective seven calendar days after the issuance of the order if Verizon fails to notify the Board that they are willing to come to a discussion and demonstrate significant commitment that they will do something “to resolve the issue to the board’s satisfaction.”
This action is the first known cease and desist by a Board of Health in the USA.
News Articles
- IBerkshires Pittsfield Health Board Seeking Funds to Stop Cell Tower 4/7/2022
- iBerkshires: Pittsfield Health Board Ordering Verizon to Remove Cell Tower, 2/2/2022
- The Berkshire Eagle: Pittsfield Board of Health asks Verizon to remove or relocate controversial South Street cell tower”
Additional Resources
- Spectrum News “Family Injured by Cell Tower” May 2021 d residents say Pittsfield cell tower causing health concernsNeighborhood residents say Pittsfield cell tower causing health concernsNeighborhood residents say Pittsfield cell tower causing health concerns
- Watch Videos from John Krol Show: Courtney Gilardi and Dr. Kent Chamberlain; Microsoft Canada head Frank Clegg, Paul Héroux, PhD;
- Watch EHT’s Interview With Gilardi Family Injured by the Pittsfield Cell Tower
- Kent Chamberlin, a retired electrical engineering Chair and professor at University of New Hampshire, presented to the nearby town of Lenox . Watch presentation which can be viewed on demand at CTSB Search “Town of Lenox Board of Health Remote Meeting, August 19, 2021, with presentation by Kent Chamberlin, Ph.D., on Cell Tower Research.”
- Letter from Paul Héroux, PhD Professor of Toxicology and Health Effects of Electromagnetism McGill University Medicine Department of Surgery, McGill University Health Center
Pittsfield MA Expert Forum on Cell Tower Cease-and-Desist Order: With Senator Denise Ricciardi, NH; Dr. Paul Héroux; Dr. Magda Havas; Dr. Kent Chamberlin; Dr. Sharon Goldberg, Environmental Health Trust Director Theodora Scarato; Attorney Robert Berg; Attorney Scott McCollough.
March 28, 2022 Pittsfield MA Expert Forum on Cell Tower Radiation Five world-leading experts join Courtney Gilardi in Pittsfield, MA in support of their Board of Health’s decision to issue a cease and desist order to Verizon for the cell tower making children and adults sick, and pollinators disappear.
Throughout the year, Verizon has contended that the tower radiation emissions were “compliant with FCC cell tower radiation limits.” However, community advocates and experts repeatedly presented evidence that compliance with FCC limits did not mean safety was assured. In August 2020, the United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit ruled in the case EHT et al. v. the FCC that the FCC had violated the Administrative Procedures Act when the agency decided not to update its 1996 wireless radiation limits. Specifically, the court found the FCC had ignored submitted evidence of people injured by wireless radiation, health effects from long term exposure and children’s unique vulnerability.
“We are finding cases like this across the U.S., where residents living near cell towers are reporting a variety of health issues,” said Devra Davis, epidemiologist and toxicologist as well as president of the Environmental Health Trust. Davis has presented findings before Congress on the dangers of wireless radiation. She was also instrumental in having smoking banned from planes and she was part of a Nobel Peace Prize team on climate change. “The Pittsfield Council, board of health and residents have taken a bold, courageous stand. Now it is time for Verizon to listen,” Davis added. She also noted that in many communities there are plans to locate towers on school grounds. “Children are particularly vulnerable to wireless radiation and I am very concerned about the future health and safety of our communities as more towers are built,” said Davis.
A cell tower was removed in Tarrytown New York after residents protested placement near a public housing complex and playground. In Dewey Beach, Delaware Verizon agreed to relocate beachfront cell towers after residents filed a lawsuit and founded the Save Dewey Beach Foundation. Ocean City Maryland and Montego Bay are in lawsuits regarding their restrictions on small cell tower installations. EHT has a list of communities enacting ordinances to limit wireless facilities in and near residential areas and prohibit cell towers near schools.
For more information on the Environmental Health Trust, visit www.ehtrust.org.